Pizza restaurants

Paisano's Restaurant

4.0 300 reviews Closed 821 E Warrington Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15210, United States

Discover this place

Located at 821 E Warrington Ave in Pittsburgh, Paisano's Restaurant has garnered a reputation as a must-try pizza spot. With enthusiastic reviews, customers highlight the exceptional quality of food and friendly service.

Shawn Painter praises their service, stating, "5-star when they're there," despite occasional inconsistencies in hours. The food compensates for any minor inconveniences, with a special mention of the hoagies, which are described as "out of this world." TJ Function echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the "top-notch crust, elite sauce, and quality cheese" that make the pizza a standout dish. Similarly, Lauren Cesnalis appreciates the authentic Italian flavor, noting the mild and balanced sauce with a rich basil presence.

Many reviews celebrate the warm atmosphere cultivated by the staff and the owner. Dominica Frazier recounts her experience of feeling recognized and valued, enhancing the dining experience. With dishes like the "bad-ass" chicken parm and an assortment of quality hoagies, Paisano's Restaurant is proudly positioned on the Pittsburgh Pizza Tour, making it a delightful destination for both locals and visitors.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Dining options

Dinner
Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Paisano's Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Paisano's Restaurant

4.0

300 reviews

Review highlights

Based on 300 reviews

Paisano's Restaurant in Pittsburgh is widely praised for its authentic Italian-style pizza and exceptional hoagies, with many customers highlighting the quality of ingredients such as fresh toppings and carefully crafted sauces. The restaurant’s crust and cheese receive frequent commendation, positioning it as a notable stop for pizza enthusiasts. Service is generally viewed as attentive and personable, with staff and management often recognized for their customer rapport. However, some patrons note inconsistent operating hours and occasional communication challenges. Despite these minor drawbacks, Paisano's enjoys a loyal following appreciative of its flavorful menu and welcoming atmosphere, making it a recommended destination for both locals and visitors seeking quality pizza and meal delivery options.

Shawn Painter

Jun 28, 2025

They have 5* service when they're there. Their hours are kinda spotty, and it's a gamble if they're going to answer the phone or not. But their food is absolutely worth it. One of my favorite pizza joints and their hoagies are out of this world.

Derek Diedricksen

Jun 24, 2025

Chicken parm was bad-ass, dude running the joint was great too. Visiting from Boston to play with a metal band- would def go back

TJ Function

Jun 21, 2025

Their pizza is undeniably good. Top notch crust, elite sauce and the cheese is quality. Definitely belongs on the Pgh Pizza Tour

Lauren Cesnalis

Jun 18, 2025

Very good authentic Italian tasting pizza. The sauce is mild and thin not too sweet not too salty. Very basil tasting which is good, toppings are good and the Kyia Liam hoagies are delicious they get the best meat around/the most expensive lunch meat and you can tell the difference. I definitely recommend Paisanos!

Dominica Frazier

Jun 08, 2025

I’ve been purchasing from this establishment for a little over a year. The employees are great, and the owner/manager definitely remembers customers by their orders and personalities. Great food, great environment, and I recommend it to all my friends and family!

Bink Bink Coleman

May 22, 2025

The best pizza. The best hoagies. And my favorite is the Steak Wedgie with everything on but no tomato sloppy mayo is the most fulfillment

pscassid11

Apr 28, 2025

Walked in here at 10PM on a Tuesday and left with the most delicious cheesesteak I've ever had since moving to Pittsburgh 5years ago! Fries were delicious too.

Pat Majeskie

Apr 13, 2025

Best pizza around. Other pizza shops have nothing on them, their crust is soft ,you can even enjoy eating it all the way till its all gone. Plenty of cheese on it, also their hoagies are the best, they are not afraid to put meat in them and lettuce tomatoes, cheese. I will not buy from anyone else. Don't change yens are number 1...thank you